09
Jan
By Mike Pfefferman
Home Buyer Tips

Why Closing Old Credit Accounts Can Hurt Your Mortgage Approval

When you are preparing to buy a home, it is natural to want your credit profile to look clean and organized. Many buyers think closing old credit accounts will improve their score, simplify their finances, and make them appear more responsible to lenders. In reality, closing old accounts can have the opposite effect. Those accounts play a much bigger role in your credit profile than most people realize and shutting them down can create sudden changes that impact your mortgage approval.

Understand How Closed Accounts Affect Your Credit History

Your credit history length is a major part of your credit score. Older accounts help build a long, strong payment record, and closing them can shorten your overall history. When you close an account, it eventually stops contributing to your average age of credit. A shorter credit history can lower your score and make your credit profile look less stable, which can affect the rate you receive or your loan approval altogether.

See How Closing Accounts Impacts Your Credit Utilization

Credit utilization is the percentage of available credit you are currently using. When you close an old card with a high limit, your total available credit drops instantly. This makes your utilization ratio go up, even if your spending stays the same. A higher utilization ratio can lower your score, and lenders view it as a sign of financial stress. Keeping older accounts open gives you more available credit and a healthier utilization ratio.

Know Why Lenders Look Closely at Recent Credit Changes

Lenders prefer to see stable, predictable financial behavior. Closing accounts shortly before applying for a mortgage can look risky because it changes your credit profile right before a major purchase. Even if your intentions are good, lenders may worry that you are trying to manage debt abruptly or hide financial strain. Consistency is key, and the fewer sudden changes you make before applying, the better.

Understand the Value of Long-Term On-Time Payments

Old accounts with long histories of on-time payments help strengthen your credit profile. These accounts show lenders that you have managed credit responsibly for years. Closing them removes some of that positive history from your active credit mix. Even if the account stays on your report for a while, the impact weakens over time. Keeping these accounts open preserves your strongest credit advantages.

Avoid Making Changes Right Before a Mortgage Application

A mortgage application is not the time to reset or rearrange your credit accounts. If you want to simplify your finances, it is best to do it after closing on your home. Before applying, avoid closing cards, opening new ones, or making large changes to your credit usage. The goal is to show lenders stability, steady habits, and a well-managed credit profile.

Closing old accounts may seem like a smart cleanup strategy, but it often hurts more than it helps during mortgage approval. By keeping your accounts open, maintaining low balances, and staying consistent, you can protect your score and present a stronger, more stable financial picture when you apply for a home loan.

12
Dec
By Mike Pfefferman
Credit Scoring

The Differences Between Hard and Soft Credit Inquiries

Credit inquiries, also known as credit pulls or checks, are a standard part of assessing creditworthiness. However, not all credit inquiries are the same. They fall into two main categories: hard and soft credit inquiries. Understanding the differences between these two types is crucial for managing your credit health and avoiding misconceptions. Below, we explore the distinctions between hard and soft credit inquiries to provide clarity on their purpose and impact.

1. Purpose and Usage

Hard and soft credit inquiries serve different purposes.

  • Soft Inquiries: These occur in situations like checking your own credit score, background checks by potential employers, or pre-approval offers from financial institutions. They are typically informational and not tied to major financial decisions.
  • Hard Inquiries: These are required when applying for a new line of credit, such as a mortgage, car loan, or credit card. Lenders use hard inquiries to evaluate your financial history and determine your loan eligibility and terms. While hard pulls are essential for lending decisions, they temporarily affect your credit score.

2. Impact on Credit Score

The effect of credit inquiries on your score is another significant difference.

  • Soft Inquiries: These have no impact on your credit score, regardless of how often they occur. For example, you can check your credit score frequently without concern, as soft pulls are unrecorded on your credit report. Institutions conducting soft inquiries without your explicit permission also don’t harm your score.
  • Hard Inquiries: These can lower your credit score, typically by one to five points per inquiry. While the impact is temporary (about one year), hard pulls remain on your credit report for two years. Excessive hard inquiries in a short period may raise red flags for lenders, suggesting financial instability or risky borrowing behavior.

3. Consent Requirements

Whether an inquiry requires your permission is another key distinction.

  • Soft Inquiries: These often occur without your consent. For example, financial institutions may perform a soft pull before sending pre-approval offers, or an employer may check your credit as part of a background screening.
  • Hard Inquiries: These require your explicit consent. For instance, when applying for a mortgage or car loan, the lender must inform you that a hard credit check will be performed. This ensures transparency, as hard inquiries affect your credit score.

Understanding the differences between hard and soft credit inquiries empowers you to make informed decisions about your credit health. Soft inquiries are harmless and routine, while hard inquiries should be minimized to maintain a strong credit profile. By managing your credit wisely, you can position yourself for financial success.

10
Dec
By Mike Pfefferman
Credit Scoring

Will Refinancing Impact Your Credit?

Refinancing a mortgage can provide significant financial benefits, such as lowering your interest rate or accessing home equity. However, it’s important to understand how the process may temporarily affect your credit score. Here’s an in-depth look at the potential short- and long-term effects of refinancing on your credit, along with tips for minimizing any negative impacts.

What Does It Mean to Refinance a Mortgage?

When you refinance, you replace your existing mortgage with a new loan. Homeowners refinance for a variety of reasons, including:

  • Lowering their interest rate
  • Changing the loan term (e.g., from 30 to 15 years or vice versa)
  • Accessing home equity through a cash-out refinance

There are two primary types of refinancing:

  • Rate-and-Term Refinance: Adjusts the loan’s interest rate, term, or both. For example, refinancing to a lower rate can reduce monthly payments, or switching to a shorter term can save on long-term interest costs.
  • Cash-Out Refinance: Lets homeowners borrow against their home equity, receiving the difference between the current loan balance and the new loan amount as cash. This option is commonly used for home improvements, debt consolidation, or large expenses.

How Does Refinancing Impact Your Credit?

Refinancing can have both short-term and long-term effects on your credit. While the short-term impacts are usually minor and temporary, it’s helpful to understand the details.

Short-Term Impacts

  1. Hard Credit Inquiries:
    When you apply for refinancing, lenders conduct a hard credit inquiry to assess your financial profile. This can temporarily lower your credit score by five to ten points. Multiple hard inquiries in a short time frame may have a larger impact, so it’s best to avoid shopping for other credit during this period.
  2. Credit Age:
    Refinancing creates a new loan account, which may lower the average age of your credit accounts—a factor in determining your score. If you don’t have other long-standing accounts, the impact may be more noticeable.
  3. Credit Utilization:
    If you choose a cash-out refinance, your total debt increases, which can raise your credit utilization ratio. This ratio is a key metric in calculating your credit score, so higher utilization can temporarily lower it.

Long-Term Benefits

Despite the initial dip, refinancing can improve your credit and financial health in the long run:

  1. On-Time Payments:
    Payment history is a major factor in your credit score. Regular, on-time payments on your new loan will strengthen your score over time and offset any short-term declines caused by the refinance process.
  2. Improved Debt-to-Income (DTI) Ratio:
    Refinancing to a lower interest rate reduces your monthly payments, freeing up income and improving your overall financial flexibility. While DTI isn’t part of your credit score, it’s an important factor for future loan approvals.
  3. Debt Consolidation with Cash-Out Refinance:
    Using a cash-out refinance to consolidate high-interest debts can lower your credit utilization ratio and boost your score. However, weigh the risks carefully, as this initially increases your total debt.

Avoid New Credit During Refinancing

Applying for additional credit, like a car loan or credit card—while refinancing can harm your credit score and disrupt the loan process. Lenders may view this as increasing your financial risk, which could jeopardize your approval.

While refinancing may result in a temporary dip in your credit score, the long-term financial benefits often outweigh these short-term effects. By understanding the process and managing your credit wisely, you can make the most of refinancing opportunities and position yourself for future financial success.